In this episode, we're joined by Tiah Tarumoto, Associate Wealth Advisor at PWL Capital, for a wide-ranging conversation about the evolving financial planning profession, the different ways Canadians can access financial advice, and what it means to be a true financial planning professional. Drawing on her experience across different advisory models, her involvement with the Financial Planning Association of Canada, and her perspective as an emerging professional, Tiah explores why financial planning is much broader than investment management and why the right advice depends on each person's circumstances.
We discuss why financial planning should be viewed as a collection of specialized services rather than a one-size-fits-all solution, how consumers can evaluate the qualifications, responsibilities, and compensation structures of financial professionals, and why professional designations alone don't necessarily guarantee expertise. Tiah also shares research on Canadians' financial stress, access to advice, and understanding of financial plans, while Ben Felix and Dan Bortolotti add their perspectives on DIY investing, financial literacy, professional collaboration, and the importance of knowing when to refer clients to specialists.
The conversation also begins with an important update at PWL Capital: Ben Felix's appointment as President and what it means for the firm's leadership, growth, investment philosophy, technology, and future. It's a thoughtful discussion about building a stronger financial planning profession—one that puts the right advice, accessibility, collaboration, and client outcomes ahead of traditional industry boundaries.
Key Points From This Episode:
(0:00:15) Why Ben Felix's appointment as President of PWL Capital marks a natural evolution in the firm's leadership.
(0:03:42) Looking back: How Ben and Cameron's complementary strengths helped shape PWL over 13 years.
(0:09:37) Why Ben's new role supports long-term leadership, succession planning, and a co-CEO-style relationship.
(0:10:47) PWL's next 12 months: Scaling the team, developing technology, and getting new advisor and client tools into wider use.
(0:12:29) Preserving culture during rapid growth: Why hiring the right people and maintaining shared values matter.
(0:16:27) PWL's growth ambitions: Why Cameron believes the firm could be 10 times its current size within a decade.
(0:20:58) The future of Rational Reminder and Ben's YouTube channel: Balancing accessible content with the technical depth audiences appreciate.
(0:22:44) How AI-powered meeting transcription is transforming PWL's financial planning checklist and advisor workflow.
(0:24:08) Turning institutional knowledge into technology: How PWL is codifying its advisors' collective financial planning expertise.
(0:25:12) Why PWL's financial planning software could become a significant marketing and client communication advantage.
(0:26:22) Why PWL remains committed to its evidence-based investment philosophy and sees it as a growing competitive advantage.
(0:35:12) Avoiding the sales-driven culture of traditional financial institutions through aligned compensation and client-focused performance measures.
(0:38:39) The advantages of scale: How a larger firm can invest in better tools, research, talent, and financial planning infrastructure.
(0:39:25) Introducing Tiah Tarumoto's central question: Does every Canadian need a financial planner, and how should they decide what advice is right for them?
(0:40:28) Tiah's journey into financial planning, from a robo-advisor to Macdonald Shymko and ultimately PWL Capital.
(0:43:27) Why financial planning should be understood as a broad professional discipline rather than a single service or investment product.
(0:45:37) Why the objective isn't to make every Canadian a financial planning client, but to help people understand and evaluate their options.
(0:49:11) Beyond the portfolio: Cash management, debt, risk management, taxes, retirement, and estate planning.
(0:50:49) The different financial advice models: Bank-based advisors, investment managers, advice-only planners, insurance professionals, and comprehensive planning firms.
(0:53:48) The numbers behind Canada's advice gap: Financial stress, access to planners, retirement confidence, and perceived value.
(0:56:10) Financial advice as a credence good: Why the value of professional guidance can be difficult to measure, even after receiving it.
(0:59:01) Why consumers need to understand what different financial professionals are qualified and licensed to provide.
(1:03:31) Knowing when to refer: Why planners need to recognize the boundaries of their expertise and bring in specialists.
(1:09:49) Conflicts of interest in financial advice: How commission-based and assets-under-management compensation can influence recommendations.
(1:13:16) Financial literacy versus professional advice: Why becoming more knowledgeable doesn't necessarily mean you no longer need expert guidance.
(1:18:37) What makes someone a financial planning professional? Why credentials, practical experience, judgment, and ethical responsibility are different things.
(1:29:19) Why future financial planners need to be excellent communicators and guides, not just technically competent professionals.
(1:37:25) Tiah's vision for the profession over the next 20 years: Better accessibility, transparent services, stronger referral systems, and professional development.
(1:43:36) Does every Canadian need a financial planner? Why the answer ultimately depends on their needs, circumstances, and access to appropriate advice.
Read The Transcript:
Ben Felix: Welcome to episode 436 of the Rational Reminder Podcast. I'm Ben Felix, President and Chief Investment Officer at PWL Capital.
Cameron Passmore: I'm Cameron Passmore, CEO at PWL Capital.
Ben Felix: All right, so today we have a really interesting conversation with Tiah Tarumoto, who is an Associate Wealth Advisor at PWL. She's relatively new to the industry, but I would call her kind of like a highly engaged high achiever. She's been heavily involved with volunteer work in the financial planning profession.
She wrote basically an essay on her observations on our industry. Dan and I are going to talk with Tiah about that a little bit later, but before we do that, you may have noticed that my title has changed. We wanted to just talk about that for a minute, but then we have a video with obviously audio as well for those listening that we did for internal use to kind of announce this to our employees, but the feedback internally was so good.
We were like, all right, well, we may as well just put this on the podcast too. I don't know. What are your thoughts, Cameron?
Cameron Passmore: Well, it's interesting. We were at our annual summit at Chateau Montebello with the whole team and we had 150 plus or minus people there and that is where we made this super important and exciting announcement to everybody. Then Angelica, who people know, sat us down with the video people and said, here's some questions I want you to ask each other just as a way to explain our thinking to the team.
In true fashion for us, we kind of just riffed after we went through the prepared questions and just frankly chatted about it for 30, 40 minutes. I agree with you. The content was pretty good.
It was pretty clear, the rationale for it, pretty clear what our vision is, the opportunity we see, and it's pretty clear what we're up to and what we're all about. I agree. In hindsight, I think it is kind of cool content.
It was not prepared at all. I don't even think we'd seen the questions beforehand. It was a complete riff and it was one take.
There was no, I don't think there's any edits to this at all, not even removal of ums and ahs and stuff. I think it was pretty clean. Yeah, why not share it?
Because we've had a bunch of questions and certainly there'll be more questions now that it's public. Yeah, why not share? We've been transparent all the way along, so why stop now?
Ben Felix: This isn't breaking news. There's been media coverage of this change already. The most common question that I've gotten or comment that I've seen is, I hope this is not going to affect my participation on the podcast.
Since we're here on the podcast, I'll tell everyone listening that no, it won't. We're making sure that this, which is an important part of our business at this point, continues to be a priority. No worries about that.
Cameron Passmore: Yeah, we don't want you further away. We talk about that in the interview, further away from the end consumer, whether you're a client or not. That's super important to keep our fingers on the pulse of what we're about and what consumers are demanding.
Knowing over time, the reality is you have become the face of the brand and the company. I think this is a very natural evolution. Now that we built out such a strong leadership team, I think it's just frankly a great call on our part.
Ben Felix: So exciting times, but we'll play that clip now and hopefully you guys enjoy that. Then we will transition to Dan, Tiah and I, where Tiah is going to talk about her observations. The two topics fit together nicely, but hopefully people enjoy all of it.
Cameron Passmore: We look forward to your feedback. Thanks.
Ben Felix: Think back to when you first started working together. What was your initial impression of each other?
Cameron Passmore: 13 years ago, you were an interesting mix of basketball guy, competitive basketball, playing Division I in the US, but also taking engineering, which at the time you said you took it because it was the hardest course of study you could do. You're an interesting mix of brains and drive to do the engineering side of it, but also a competitive, very aggressive feedback nature of playing competitive basketball.
As you said, you weren't the best on the team and others were so much better than you were, but you were still part of a Division I team. So it's an interesting mix of being able to do the analytics, be competitive. The part that I didn't appreciate at the time, which I don't think you had at the time was to take that drive, apply it to learning, and then turn all of that into understandable stories for the end public.
And that has turned out to be, I would argue, your greatest gift. But the other part that you had from your basketball time was standards. And you helped the company, the practice evolve from a practice, which was largely a hustle-based practice, which is kind of the old world of how the industry worked, to applying these standards, which were absolutely vitally needed as the team grew.
Standards on quality of work, quality of research, quality of communications, precision of use of words. I think that goes back to education and the West Coast. That's my take.
Ben Felix: We first met, yep, so it was 13 years ago, and you had a vision. We all had a vision. PWL was a firm that I had admired for a bit.
I was still pretty new in the industry, but I had looked at PWL as the standard, as doing our business the way that it should be done. Then when we met and I spoke with you, you laid it out on a whiteboard in the office as you used to do. The vision, the vision and the opportunity for what you saw ahead of your practice at the time and where you thought it could go and where you thought I could fit into it.
That was very compelling to me as a young person starting out in our industry. That opportunity that you saw and the vision that you had has come to fruition more than either of us could have imagined at the time.
Cameron Passmore: That vision goes back 30 years, to the founding of the firm.
Ben Felix: For sure. The firm was an expression of a vision. You saw an opportunity for it to become something much greater than it was.
I think it has become even more than that. The other thing that I couldn't have known at the time, but learned very, very quickly is that you are very trusting of the people that you put around you. I've seen you hire a ton of people, me and then a few other people after me and then many, many more people since then.
You've always been big on delegation and you've always been huge on trust, which it comes back to standards in your own way. You expect people to do a very good job when they say they're going to do something and you trust them to do it. I think that's one of the things that's allowed our team to be as successful and our firm to be as successful as it has been.
Cameron Passmore: What is one professional strength the other has that you deeply admire and know you don't possess yourself?
Ben Felix: You've got a vision and you've got discipline to avoid being distracted by stuff that's not central to the mission. I think I do have a tendency to get distracted sometimes where there's an interesting project or a technology or a line of business where I'm like, hey, we should look at this. You've always been so good at entertaining it to be nice probably, but being pretty firm about it's not core of the mission. It's not part of the core service that we want to deliver. We're not going to touch it.
Cameron Passmore: Well, your strength to me is dead obvious. I used to admire, still admire Larry Swedroe, was one of the early great communicators in our space. I would argue right now, and we've done enough conversations with enough people to have a good sense of who's out there.
There is no one that I've been able to find on the planet that is able to take these important concepts and make them understandable and applicable to the average investor. To have you as part of the team is a privilege, but it's also a privilege for the Canadian public to be able to have access to this level of thinking and rigor. The industry as a whole doesn't give what you represent nearly enough credit and attention that I think it deserves. It is so important, but most people just don't have the technical ability to understand it, all the Greek letters, and then to turn that into the English language to make a difference in the communications that you put out through the podcast and YouTube channel, through the talent that we attract, and then put those all together to be able to help people in real life situations in plain English. So that's a real magic you've been able to figure out.
Ben Felix: It's interesting to think about the podcast as an expression of both of the strengths that we just articulated about each other. I was still a relatively new employee when I was like, hey, let's do a podcast. You were like, let's do it. You trusted that it was a good idea. You invested the resources to make it happen.
Cameron Passmore: You didn't know who you were at that time.
Ben Felix: No, no.
Cameron Passmore: You didn't know that this would become what it became. I think as it started to pick up steam, I think it put some fuel into you that you saw you were on to something.
Ben Felix: None of us knew. I started making videos. People go back and watch my first videos. I was so nervous on camera and so stiff and rigid. We did it. Why appoint a president now?
Cameron Passmore: So you and I have been working together very closely for 13 years. I think it's just a natural, strategic place that we are both at.
I think it's also prudent for the business to make sure that there's good long-term, serious attention and discipline put into the leadership of the company for the next five, 10, 20 plus years. There's a 22-year age service between us. I think that's a good amount of time between us.
I'm not going anywhere, but you have so much more to bring. It's good to have, frankly, more attention and more eyes on all the big rocks of the business. So you'll be a president, but we'll be acting very much like a co-CEO model, which I think it gives us a lot of time to do a lot of things together. And also, to the public, you are PWL to so much of the public and not just the investing client public, but also our industry. You have such a great brand in the industry. I think it's a signal to the industry that we're committed to you. You're committed to the mission of the firm, which I think is good for everybody.
Ben Felix: I'm excited about all of it and I'm looking forward to the future. It's all very exciting to be doing that with you.
Cameron Passmore: What are some important goals or milestones you both are locked in on achieving together over the next 12 months?
Ben Felix: I think what we're doing right now with, first of all, we have a massive opportunity in front of us through teams that we're attracting, through clients that are continuing to express interest in becoming clients of PWL. So I think continuing to execute on that and capitalize on the opportunity that we have in front of us is a necessity. On top of that, what we're doing right now with technology, what we've been building in terms of tools for advisors and tools for our clients is, I think, you can tell me what you think, but I think it's setting us apart more and more every day relative to where everyone else is in the industry.
I think taking what we're doing there, getting it into the hands of our advisors as much as possible, getting it into the hands and in front of our clients, hopefully soon within the next 12 months, I think is going to drive a larger wedge between where we are and what we can deliver to clients and where the rest of our industry is.
Cameron Passmore: And that is all possible because of the people. We have people that are part of one team, that have one mission, one purpose, one philosophy, one belief system, the drive to help each other be better. So if that did not exist, we could not build the data lake.
We could not build the tools that will make this team better because everyone's trying to make the thing better as opposed to being better themselves for their own outcomes. So to me, it's all about the team. So over the next 12 months, we certainly have to build out leadership because we are growing so fast, build out training programs and be big focused on that. And then also just to capture this opportunity because there is no firm like us in Canada.
Ben Felix: Part of capturing the opportunity too, and it's a big part of what we have to execute on over the next 12 months, is making sure that the team keeps pace with the growth that we're having. And that's not easy to do, but we've been very, very fortunate to have incredible people continue to want to join our firm and be part of what we're doing and be part of the mission. But we need to continue adding to our team, to our talent pool.
As we scale, how do we ensure the core culture and values that got us here don't get lost in the transition?
Cameron Passmore: Again, it's about the people. The philosophy and the drive for quality and the client concern is so paramount that we're the best place for a person that believes in that. If you don't believe in that, we're the worst place for you.
So there's this, I think there'll be a massive self-selection out if someone doesn't fit. I just think we're so strong culturally now that when you think about it, we're 150 people plus or minus. Apple is tens of thousands of people and they have a very strong culture.
So I think the culture can absolutely continue. And the fact that we are attracting people who want to make this place better helps that kind of self-propel itself.
Ben Felix: I would even argue that as we've gotten larger, our culture has gotten stronger rather than weaker because of the people who are choosing to join our firm. If I wanted to change something central to who we are and to our philosophy, it would be very hard, I would get absolutely roasted by all the people at the firm.
Cameron Passmore: But if on the flip side, if you did want to change something, people would know that you've done a ton of research and show respect, and that there's nothing flippant and that there's no rash decisions. There's no storytelling type decisions that happen.
Ben Felix: Yeah. If that due diligence had not been done, the type of people that we have at this firm would see through it in a second.
Cameron Passmore: Because they're so well-trained.
Ben Felix: It's central to the culture. Those are the types of people that we've attracted. It's because of who we've been able to attract. And a lot of that comes back to things like the podcast, but also the people that are already here.
We're attracting more and more like-minded people. As long as we can continue doing that, I'm not worried about culture. I think culture will continue to get stronger rather than weaker.
Cameron Passmore: Agreed. What do you see as our biggest hurdle in the next few years and how do we tackle it together?
Ben Felix: I think it's probably scaling the team and continuing to find the right people to fill the roles as we need more and more people to deliver the service that we want to to clients.
Cameron Passmore: Yeah. We've had so many hurdles. We just keep knocking them down. I think back over the last six years, going back to when we reorganized six years ago, all of that seems so quaint now.
So I think there's a certain feeling of power, but not in an arrogant way. I think we feel good about our ability to make decisions and just handle what comes our way as a full team. There's been so many changes so quickly happen that just happen now and more great people arrive and more impact keeps happening and cool tools are built and new communication strategies are come up with. It's just happening at such a rapid pace. I think we're almost used to just rapid change.
Ben Felix: You're right. We've overcome so many hurdles to get here. There will be more, and maybe some that we can't even imagine, but I think we've gotten pretty good at addressing them head on and overcoming them.
Cameron Passmore: But we do have to build out basically every team. It's not hard to imagine that we could be doubling again in the next couple of years. So with that comes a lot of complexity from leadership to reporting, to all the financial metrics of it, to space constraints, to travel budgets.
I mean, the list goes on and on and on. So a lot of new things we have to solve, but that's, I think we have enough experience now with how many years we've all been working together and the quality of the team. So I'm not worried about it. It's going to be an incredibly exciting time.
Ben Felix: What are your reflections or thoughts when thinking about PWL from 10 years ago to today to 10 years into the future?
Cameron Passmore: Well, look, in the past two years, we've helped more new families than we helped in the previous 28 years. That is a staggering statistic. That doesn't mean the first 28 years were not important.
They were absolutely important. It built the foundation and they were wildly successful years. So this rate of change, to imagine what it could be like in 10 years from now, it's not hard to imagine, and I've said this often, we could be 10 times the size.
We should be 10 times the size in 10 years. This country deserves it. We are a very large, small firm, but we could be a very, I won't say large, large firm because we're dominated by huge firms, but there's no reason why we can't be 10 times, 20 times in the next 10 years.
I sometimes think we think too small about how fast we could have an impact with more families.
Ben Felix: Ten years ago, we were still running a practice within a larger PWL that had several practices underneath it. And since then we became one team delivering one service with one philosophy, which was loosely true with the initial iteration of PWL, but even more so now. We've joined OneDigital, which gave us access to, among other things, capital to do acquisitions. We've had many teams, external teams join us, and there's a very, very clear path to having more teams join us in the future.
It's very different. 10 years ago, it was a few of us with some ideas about what the future could look like. But even then, relative to how things worked out, we were thinking way too small.
Cameron Passmore: Way too small. Just imagine where we could have offices. We now have offices in two new provinces just in the past year. We could have an office in every major city in every province in the next 10 years.
Ben Felix: And we could help countless Canadians, many more than we are today.
Cameron Passmore: So what are you thinking about the role of president?
Ben Felix: I've got my hands in a lot of different parts of PWL right now. I think formalizing that role and that title is going to do a lot to take things off of your plate and change some of the reporting structures that we have in place now.
Cameron Passmore: Yeah, but it's not like your plate's exactly a lot of white space on it.
Ben Felix: Yeah. The other obvious problem that we're going to need to solve that's going to stem directly from this president title change is solving for a CIO that is not me.
So that's something that I've been working on talking to people within the firm, which is my ideal.
Cameron Passmore: And that was needed regardless of this appointment or not.
Ben Felix: Likely. Yeah. The CIO role is becoming increasingly time-consuming. M&A has been transformational for the investment function at PWL because it's brought in just by the nature of doing acquisitions.
It's brought in teams and firms and advisors and clients that have portfolios that for whatever reason are different from what we have historically been doing. So we've done a whole reformation of the investment committee, which has been fantastic. And that committee is great to work with.
The people on it are great, but the CIO chairs that committee and is responsible for working with the research team to get KYP reports into the hands of the investment committee so they can vote on things. There's also tons of decisions throughout each week and through each acquisition that we do, but also just stuff that comes up over time, speaking with advisors about a strange situation that a client comes in with, speaking with the M&A team about an advisor that we're looking at, whether we'd be willing to take the securities that they own, all that kind of stuff. So it's, yes, it was a problem we had to solve.
Cameron Passmore: How do you think the market, especially the market of advisors, or even some of the media like Globe and Mail and stuff, how do you think the message of you becoming president, is there a lift there for you?
Ben Felix: I don't know. That's a good question. I think you said it earlier. People associate me with the PWL brand very, very heavily, whether my title's president and CIO for a bit, or CIO or president, I don't know if it'll have a big impact.
I think it does send a very positive signal in terms of thinking about the future and succession of the firm. I see no downside there and it'll probably be perceived positively, but I don't think it's going to be a big splash. I don't know.
Cameron Passmore: Paint me a picture of your content over the next five years and where are the great opportunities? We talked about speaking to more normal people as opposed to nerdier people.
Ben Felix: Listen, we've done videos and podcast episodes over the last year that have been much less nerdy and much more accessible to typical people. I've got a video that I'm working on right now that's as nerdy as anything I've ever done. I think there's some balance there because the nerdiness is what people come to the channel for.
I don't want to give that up, but I think continuing to create content that's more accessible is going to be good. We've seen the channels, the podcast and my YouTube channel have by halfway through this year had matched or exceeded the total number of views that we had through all of last year.
Cameron Passmore: What's the ballpark number of that?
Ben Felix: It's around 8 million views on my channel. Rational Reminder, I can't remember what the number is. I think it's over a million. That is real, real numbers.
Cameron Passmore: Do you see more people on the team getting involved in producing the content?
Ben Felix: I think that's necessary. You obviously have stepped back a little bit from the podcast. You're still coming on occasionally, but less often. We've had Dan Bortolotti step in. We've had Ben Wilson step in. We've had Louai step in, Braden. We've had advisors on.
I think that thinking very seriously about succession and who can be a consistent anchor, co-host or host of the podcast in the future is something we're going to have to plan for. It's a necessity. I'm not planning on going anywhere, but because the podcast has become so important to our business, we need to have...
Cameron Passmore: Well, you are a single point of failure.
Ben Felix: Correct.
Cameron Passmore: So you mentioned Braden. Riff on the tool that he and others, of course, it takes a village to build what is being built now, but the rate of change and the benefit that it's creating is truly breathtakingly staggering and fast. Where do you see that going?
Ben Felix: Braden's taking the vision that you had many years ago.
Cameron Passmore: You and me on that whiteboard.
Ben Felix: Yes. Well, the general vision that you had and then the more specific vision that we had with respect to software, he's taken that, he's made it into something that's not just there for advisors to use because the seed of that idea, the very first version of it, we showed it to advisors and they looked at it like, oh, that is going to be so much work to do. And we've gone from there to their jaws being on the floor because of how easy it's going to make it for them to do fantastic work for their clients. And that's all through development that Braden and the team have done to take rather than manual input, the big innovation was AI transcription of meeting notes to fill out our financial planning checklist.
Cameron Passmore: But the cascading benefits of it go back to you and your standards because you always had this dream about every client in a similar situation has to have certain levels of service and certain points of service done for them. Like if there's a change in, pick any topic you want, how can we quickly identify all the clients that might affect, A, B, make sure they've been communicated to about this as an option and how do you track that at a diamond team level, at a firm-wide level from a quality control standpoint, but also from a help advisors to do the job because it does become complicated in this world of high service.
Ben Felix: That was the vision and we were there, we can do that now and it'll only get better as advisors have meetings with clients, and the checklist gets filled out. That was the broad vision. I think what made it come to life was Braden started working on on the tool on interface for the checklist.
But really the backbone of the whole project is we call it the checklist, the database of financial planning items that might apply to clients in different situations. Building out that checklist was a, it was a multi-year project that many of our advisors touched and some of our newly acquired, newly joined advisors are now iterating and making that list better. But that thing, it's, it's a document that becomes the knowledge base for the advisor application that Braden's been building.
And that database of planning strategies and ideas and thinking is only going to get better as we add more talented, experienced advisors who can go through that document and add their own knowledge and ideas. It's incredible. It coalesces all of the knowledge and experience and wisdom that our advisor team, broadly speaking, has into a piece of software that everybody can use.
Cameron Passmore: Do you see that tool mainly, aside from doing high quality from a growth standpoint, do you see the tool mainly driving referrals or is that something that could be wrapped up into a marketing communications strategy?
Ben Felix: It's already being used for marketing. We haven't gone external with it yet. Braden's done some webinars, maybe.
It's already being used as a sales tool where advisors are showing it to clients. This is what we do for you.
Cameron Passmore: But I'm saying to go to public, say this is what a quality plan looks like because every advisor, most advisors say they do planning, right? It's just something they do, but we know that it's all different.
Ben Felix: It's a huge marketing opportunity. Huge.
Cameron Passmore: So let's go on the marketing angle a bit more. So people are blown away in the industry that we know, from Dimensional, they come to Canada and they said advisors' minds are blown once they kind of see the light about how markets work. This is a 30-year-old phenomenon in the US, but it still happens every day in Canada. How much advantage do we have having that philosophy?
Do you see that philosophy kind of waning or do you see still lots of opportunity to compel people that this really does work and you don't need something more complicated than that to have a great investment experience?
Ben Felix: I don't think it's waning. I think it's getting stronger and we do see that in the flows data where index funds and Dimensional funds are continuing to attract assets in Canada. We know from speaking with the folks at Dimensional that they're growing and adding new advisors like crazy.
I think it's only getting stronger and I think it's going to continue to be a central part of our firm and our competitive advantage, staying true to that philosophy. There have been so many opportunities where we could have, as many firms have done, strayed from that core philosophy and done X, Y, and Z. We've chosen not to do those things and I think it's benefited us significantly.
After the fact, we know that because a lot of those alternative asset classes that a lot of other people have been using have not worked out so well. I don't think that it's anything that we need to change. I think it continues to be a competitive advantage and the fact that our whole team is here really because of not just that, but that being a big part of it, it's not going to go away.
What do you think is most exciting when you look toward the next 10 years at PWL?
Cameron Passmore: For me, it's just to see the team evolve. The most fun I have is seeing how people can just turn into these unbelievable characters, unbelievable advisors or whatever role they might be in and just to see this rate of change, of advancement and talent. With the team being, our average advisor, I think is in their 30s, our average employee is low 40s. We have so much runway to have such a great impact. That to me is by far the most exciting.
For me, for the team, it's just to be able to help more people. This is about helping people. We don't talk about EBITDA and margin.
That all takes care of itself when you do great work. We're not here to create the margin. We're here to do the work and by doing great work, you end up with a great business.
Ben Felix: When you look back to say 14 years ago, right before we met, although we'd already met once briefly, but before we properly met.
Cameron Passmore: That was the time you never called me back?
Ben Felix: Yeah, that was the time. You had a vision. You saw an opportunity. Things have worked out probably better than you expected.
What do you think has surprised you the most with respect to how things have actually turned out relative to what you saw back then?
Cameron Passmore: The people that joined the team, to a person. It was just two of us on the team way back when. It was easy because what I didn't do, Laurent did.
What Laurent didn't do, I did. It was pretty binary job descriptions, but to have met person after person after person and to now have this team that's been together for on average well over a decade and had it not been for you, for others to have joined, I don't think this movie would have played out because so much opportunity came to us so fast for reasons that everybody knows to have been able to keep up with what came at us was truly unbelievable. We experienced what I'm guessing at the time, very few if any other teams in the industry in North America had ever experienced. That rate of meeting new people with real money who were all in, and what we were doing to pull that off, and then to go through the reorg that we did six years ago.
So, so many things had to line up properly and then to meet Mike and the team from OneDigital and then go through all the political chaos during the time of announcement. I don't think any of us could have imagined this would play out and have such strong markets. To be up so far this year overall, something around 35% year to date from market, new teams joining, new families joining us.
That was not on either of our cards this year, but we're keeping up. We're adding roughly a new team member a week. This rate of change and being able to keep up.
We're about to go into this summit with everyone where the excitement level, and I've talked to so many people as to what they're thinking coming into this, and they're like over the top excited to see everybody. Like that's pretty unique. I think we're the only scaled team with this philosophy and this dedication and this age in the industry in Canada, and then you add on the growth rate. I mean, it's just like, it's an unbelievable dream come true.
Ben Felix: What do you think we need to do differently over the next 10 years to continue to be successful relative to what we have been doing?
Cameron Passmore: I'm not sure if we do anything differently. We're pretty good at adapting to change. We're pretty good like culturally we're not controlling.
I've never been a controller like you said earlier. It's all about delegate and elevate player coach models. I think that is culturally part of who we are.
I think if someone tries to have too much control or push too many levers too hard, I think you could erode. I think we talk too much about the business and economics of the business that's a turnoff that takes care of itself when you do great work. So I'm not sure they we do anything differently.
Just keep up that delegation to elevate. Don't control too much and just embrace what's coming and we're pretty good at that. I think it's a safe space for debate.
I think we accept dissension. No one knows the truth but stuff now is changing so fast with the tools, how the team prepares for meetings, how the team presents, what our tech stack looks like compared to like five years ago. It's a completely different world and if you were a controlling individual, if I wasn't who I was by being a delegated profile, there's no way, you guys would have all left.
You're way too smart, way too assertive, way too competitive to put up with some sort of command and control system. No chance. The one risk I think we do have is if we let our guard down on who we let in.
Mike says that often, right? It's who you let in the front door that really matters, so that can have an impact on culture, but we're pretty set in our ways for good reasons. Because I think about this often, like I ended up believing in Markowitz/Dimensional world and then now you've gone through with 430 podcast episodes of research, 150 videos of research and come to the same conclusion. Part of me is like, phew, thank god, but it's like man, like even that was, I won't say luck because, the level of rigor and due diligence that I did, I can't do what you have done, but we ended up at the same spot, right?
So there's a certain eye to quality that we all have so that was the big attraction for me to this whole story that markets work. It's also an efficiency story which I'm always looking for from a business management standpoint. It's just a beautiful story and I have no desire to be the smartest person in the room which I think is a huge issue in my opinion in this industry because so many people have a story to tell, they're invested in their story and their story drives their economic outcome and as soon as something that is observably mathematically arguably better, you get this cognitive dissonance and a lot of people they just can't make the shift because there's economic downside to it. But we built this foundation, this thinking that I think will protect us from that kind of weaving and bobbing based on stories that come along.
Ben Felix: As we continue to grow as a business and we have a leadership team that's increasingly separated from the end clients, what do you think we have to do to maintain a client first focus?
Cameron Passmore: That is a great question. I think we need to spend more time with advisors and perhaps more time with the end client to make sure we don't lose touch with that. I think that's absolutely vital.
I think there is a risk of becoming isolated in your ivory tower and lose touch. I think we both talk a lot to the advisor team now. I think we've got a pretty good handle on it but yeah, we cannot let red tape bureaucracy get in the way of that. What do you think?
Ben Felix: Yeah, I think staying connected to the advisors, listening very closely to what they're saying because they're obviously the ones interacting with the clients and then when we have opportunities to do so, listening directly to and interacting with clients. There is a risk. I mean, we started as a practice where we were directly interfacing with the clients.
I think there is a risk of turning into a business, not that we don't want to be a business but a business that's focused on the success of the business without focusing on the success of the client. I don't think we're there.
Cameron Passmore: But you've also put in a mechanism to get advisors on the podcast. We get feedback from listeners.
There is a feedback loop there from the end consumer for sure. If questions come through the advisors, you're there to help, train, support, how to answer them, what's the research behind it. I think the feedback loop is pretty tight.
Ben Felix: Yeah, it's a good feedback loop. We hear from people in the Rational Reminder community, in YouTube comments, directly from advisors who are talking to the clients. There's a lot of feedback happening, no doubt. We've had people join PWL from the banks for the reason that they did not like the sales pressure that they had when they were working at the bank. How do we avoid ourselves ending up in a similar situation?
Cameron Passmore: The ideas we represent are bigger than all of us. The culture, the quality, the focus on the end client. I just don't see us becoming a sales organization.
We talk about helping more families. How do you build up the proper number of diamond teams, the training models, the learning sessions to become better at their roles to career path different people. I'm not worried about that at all.
These ideas are so powerful and clients are coming because of that. The advisors are seeing the power of communicating these ideas well. It's just happening. I don't worry about it. Do you worry about it?
Ben Felix: We're not incentivizing or penalizing individual performance, which I think is where it becomes a problem with the banks. We're not paying commissions to sell financial products, which is again, where I think you run into that issue of incentives conflicting with what is best for the end client.
Because we're not doing those things, I don't think it's a huge problem. Then you also think about what we are actually evaluating and you look at things like the financial planning checklist tool that we're building with the intention of evaluating advisors on how complete the financial planning work they're doing for clients is, which has nothing to do with sales or revenue targets. I think we're setting ourselves up for ongoing success with respect to how we evaluate and compensate advisors.
Cameron Passmore: It's also a very different business. The average bank has one in six or one in seven Canadians as clients. They're all fighting over the same pool.
If you can put in a systematic process across a thousand advisors and you move the needle half a percent, then you get... You can see how this could be spreadsheeted quite easily, but it just, I think, rips the culture out of the service orientation. Whereas we're such change agents right now, we're antithetical to how the banks operate.
We're antithetical to how the banks make money. We're antithetical about the investment belief system. We're antithetical because we have a single belief system.
When you take all those together, the public is getting much smarter and they're saying, this team is onto something. It's so clear. We all love our banks.
I love having a strong banking system, but when it comes to dealing with the end client, so many people are becoming enlightened and realizing that the banks can't do, and maybe they don't want to do what we do because it's very labor intensive and maybe it's a lower margin business, but it's a great opportunity for us in there, I think.
Ben Felix: We have a belief system. We have a philosophy, but we also have outreach. We can reach Canadians with the content that we create, which is something that...
Cameron Passmore: You can speak to your mind without annoying three quarters of the sales force.
Ben Felix: Yeah. There are other teams, practices across Canada that have a similar philosophy and belief system and do great financial planning work, but they don't have people knocking down their door saying, I want to work with you guys.
I want to use your service because they don't have the same level of outreach that we do. There are some people making content and there are lots of people getting referrals and things like that, but not at the scale that we're doing it. Scale has so many benefits for the service we're able to provide, the tools we're able to build and invest in.
Cameron Passmore: I love the scaling debate. That's the conversation I had with Peter Lazaroff on his podcast. There's a lot of independent advisors that are taking potshots at scaled firms.
There's beauty in scale. If we didn't have scale, we couldn't have so many things we have today.
Ben Felix: The tools we're building are because of the scale that we have. We wouldn't be able to do it otherwise. We talked about this earlier, but it's in short order and very soon it's going to set us apart from every other advisor in Canada in a way that it's going to be very hard to compete against.
Cameron Passmore: Plus, how do you know you're getting quality financial planning if you're... I'm not saying you can't, but when you look at the caliber of the planners on this team, this has to make a better planning outcome. There's no way that you can compete with the caliber of people here as an independent practitioner.
Ben Felix: The caliber, but we're codifying the level of financial planning that we do into software. I think that's what sets it apart. We're bringing the level of the whole team up to the level of the best financial planner that we have at PWL because we're putting their thinking into software.
Tiah has written an essay, I think, on answering the question of: Does every Canadian need a financial planner and how should they decide what kind of advice is right for them? Tiah, you sent this to me and said, what do you think of this? I was like, this is great. You should come on the podcast and talk about it. Here we are.
Tiah Tarumoto: It definitely was a passion project that I've been thinking about for a while and then kind of exploded. Seeing it turn into something tangible is super exciting. I'm super stoked to be here.
Ben Felix: Yeah, we're excited to have you here. You'll go through your thinking on this topic, answering that question. Dan and I are going to add our thoughts. I should add, I didn't say your title, Tiah . You're an Associate Wealth Advisor at PWL.
Tiah Tarumoto: Yeah. For a bit of background, I entered the industry about just over three years ago and I've been incredibly fortunate. I entered through a really unique path.
I started with an amazing group of advisors at a robo-advisor firm and then I joined a small, highly respected financial planning and wealth management team in Vancouver for two and a half years. Then we were M&A'd by PWL Capital earlier this year, which is super, super exciting. Naturally, I'm a very ambitious individual and I'll talk to anyone.
I'd probably talk to a rock if it seemed interested, but I also believe in luck and I'm super lucky to land in a community of planners who just, they're great people doing great work for Canadians.
Ben Felix: You were at Macdonald Shymko, I think we're okay to say the name of the firm, which is one of the longest standing financial planning firms in Canada, or I guess was.
Tiah Tarumoto: Yeah, 1972.
Ben Felix: Yeah, it's wild. PWL was super excited to bring them into our team. What was that like for you when that all went down?
Tiah Tarumoto: It was super exciting. The philosophy transposed over perfectly and just the culture that you guys have created and the new friends that I have and the people that I get to mingle with, it's been amazing. Nothing shy of amazing.
Ben Felix: Is the PWL community of financial planners as nerdy as Dan and I make them sound on the podcast?
Tiah Tarumoto: Probably even more, which I didn't think was possible, but I guess it is.
Dan Bortolotti: We like to raise the bar for sure.
Tiah Tarumoto: Entering from that specific entrance point, I generally liked to listen more than I spoke, not because I don't like talking, but because I just was genuinely so curious about the environment that I was thrown into. When you look at the whole holistic view of the profession, we're a bunch of unicorns. What we do is typically strange and not average.
So I just spent a lot of time absorbing these planners' thoughts and how they serve their clients and the value proposition that they brought to the practice. And at the same time, thinking from the perspective of a student or an early career professional, I kind of saw how difficult this profession is to navigate. There's such a diverse group of services that are provided, but it's so hard to see the full breadth of it because the industry is so dominated by the larger institutions.
And if many advisors themselves can't define the profession clearly, then how is the average Canadian supposed to understand it? I'll be the first to say, there's still so much that I'm learning and there's still so much that I don't know. But I think that's precisely why this conversation matters.
And I think it's a really good opportunity to bring different perspectives to light and kind of help educate people and bring this conversation up. The specific question that I want to explore is, does every Canadian need a financial planner and how should they decide what kind of advice is right for them? And unfortunately, I don't have a definitive answer and I don't expect you guys to either.
But I think it's certainly why this conversation is really valuable. When I was writing this proposal, or essay per se, coincidentally, David Chilton's episode, I think it was what, 433 released? And he kind of touched base on some of these topics.
I've introduced myself to this man three times and he's starting to think that I think she's a little crazy, but anyways, I digress. But basically his response through the entire episode was, it truly depends. It honestly really depends.
It's the answer that no one wants to hear, but it depends. And that is, whether you're a DIY investor, just a finance nerd, an existing client of PWL, or a client somewhere else, or even just someone looking for that service, do you truly understand the financial support that you're looking for and the support that you need? And on the other aspect of it, if you're a professional, like an established planner or advisor, do you actually understand the type of advice that you aspire to provide?
And so that being said, financial planning should be understood as a broad professional discipline, not necessarily a single service or something that's tied to a specific product. I think Canadians naturally have diverse financial needs that have varying levels of complexity and different angles that need to be accounted for. And many don't truly understand the full breadth of advice that's out there.
If we can understand and comprehend that, it would contribute to a stronger profession.
Ben Felix: I think it goes both ways too. I don't know if consumers always understand what financial advice is or what their expectations should be, but to your point, and I think this is why your perspective on this is so interesting Tiah, is that you're relatively new to the industry. You've seen a bunch of different aspects of it.
You're heavily involved with volunteer work within the financial planning community. And so you've got, I think, probably a broader view than a lot of people who are newer have. But a lot of folks, as I think you mentioned earlier, or maybe it's later in your notes, they get exposed to a single channel where it's like you get a job at a bank and then you think that's what financial advice is and what financial planning is, or you work for a firm and that's the view that you get.
But there are so many different models and ways to deliver financial advice and people have such diverse needs. I do think it's an important topic.
Tiah Tarumoto: I've talked to so many people out there. A lot of people agree, but there's also a lot of people that are very jaded and biased in their ways because they've been doing it for 20 plus years. Of course, the client demographic that they're specifically serving, yes, it makes sense to them, but it creates these blinders for them and how they see the profession, which I have empathy with and I can understand it.
But I also think there's an importance of having that growth mindset and seeing it from the bigger picture and the bigger perspective. The objective of this conversation is not to make every Canadian a client of a financial planner. It's specifically just to give education and give people the appropriate resources to understand, access, and evaluate and use financial services.
And before I go any further, I just want to be super clear. None of this is meant to criticize anyone's current setup or imply that anyone is doing anything wrong because if that looks like holding a higher fee mutual fund at a large institution, that is meaningfully better than nothing at all. So any proactive step forward, I think is amazing and better than doing nothing.
And as I'm sure you guys would agree, accessing the market is already a positive, proactive step forward, even if it's with a high fee mutual fund. So the goal here isn't really necessarily to diminish that, but simply to add additional context to help others understand the broader landscape so people can make more well-informed decisions that align with their long-term goals.
Ben Felix: I'd be interested in your thoughts for a second, Dan, because you've seen a lot of different angles too, where you started out blogging, talking about the merits of do-it-yourself investing. You spent a little bit of time doing the fee-only planning service for charity that you and Justin did that we talked about in a previous episode. And then you moved into being an advisor. So you've seen, I guess, the trade-offs for different ways of accessing advice.
Dan Bortolotti: I think among a lot of Canadians, there is a general tendency to conflate the terms financial planner and investment advisor, and they have very, very specific meanings in our industry. But I think in the broader public, they're not necessarily separate. So people will sometimes, I mean, in fact, I've had a lot of people say, you know, in the last year since I stopped doing the blog, let's say, I've seen comments where people have said, basically the blog is useless now because with asset allocation ETFs, you no longer need to get instructions on how to build a portfolio.
I said, well, that's probably true, but building a portfolio is like the easiest part of a financial plan. I can do that for a client in a very short period of time. Once you know what their risk tolerance is, building the portfolio is a breeze.
Managing it is maybe a little bit harder, but the financial plan is so much more than just that. And so I've certainly seen over the years, people who tried to do DIY because they thought all they needed to do was buy some investment funds and go on autopilot, and then eventually realized, A, managing a portfolio of multiple accounts is a little bit more complicated than it originally seems, but then B, more important, that's great that you've got a portfolio, but how do you actually design the portfolio with a financial plan in mind? What is the context of your investment plan? And that's just a lot harder to understand on your own than it is, say, working with a planner to help you with that context.
Tiah Tarumoto: I will say that I think the portfolio is such a highlighted specific thing because it's tangible. It's easy to see. And you look at FP Canada's framework.
They've got cash management, risk management, tax planning, retirement planning, estate planning. Those are all components. It's not just the investment management that matters.
It's all pillars. You look at what that entails, and you've got managing debt, buying a home. You're balancing competing priorities and competing goals.
You're preparing for retirement. How do you draw down those investments? Minimizing taxes, protecting your family, or looking at your estate plan and how that aligns with yourself. So there's a lot. It's not just the portfolio component, which I think people misunderstand.
Dan Bortolotti: It's hard to appreciate sometimes how complex or how many different facets there are of the financial plan. It's difficult to be an expert in all of them. For example, as a DIY investor, if you put in the effort, it's relatively straightforward to understand how to build a portfolio, even how to allocate it across TFSA, RRSP, non-registered, et cetera.
That's relatively easy to learn. What about the tax planning piece? What about retirement planning?
This is one thing that I would say, again, when we look at who needs a planner and who doesn't. You could be a very successful do-it-yourself investor during the accumulation phase, and things change a lot when it's time to draw down those funds. By the same token, things like estate planning is not something that almost anybody really thinks about outside of the profession. So it's hard to be an expert in all of those.
Tiah Tarumoto: You've got so many different roles and titles, like you were saying earlier, Dan. You've got bank-based advisors, investment managers, advice-only planning, insurance professionals, comprehensive financial planning firms, each offering different services, operating under different compensation structures, and serving different needs. It just gets increasingly confusing to the consumer, but also to the practitioner as well, because there's so much going on and it's really hard to navigate.
And so the questions that I've boiled it down to is, which advice do they need? Who is qualified to provide it? How much did it cost?
And whether a single service aligns with their interests. And from the perspective of an emerging professional, I think it's increasingly valuable because it highlights experiences of people who are entering the profession and their educational and career pathways that are available to them, and how the next generation can meaningfully contribute to a more trust-accessible and clearly understood profession. That is the end goal.
If I can see that in 20 years, I would be more than happy. I would be more than happy. And a recent analogy that I've taken to using is comparing the financial planning profession and financial services profession to healthcare.
To be completely honest, there is a reason I am not in biology. I think it's just a great analogy. Jokes aside, I learned that I don't have a prostate probably a few years ago, and I don't need to get it checked. Like biology is not my thing by any means.
Dan Bortolotti: Apparently.
Tiah Tarumoto: I think it's a good comparison because in healthcare, whatever issues you're having, people choose practitioners according to their needs. There's specialists that collaborate. They refer out patients when they deem it appropriate. I think financial planning should reflect something similar with its diverse needs.
Ben Felix: It's tough too, right? In Ontario, they've tried some level of title protection for our profession, and I don't know how much it's actually accomplished because so many different overlapping designations and designations of different levels of credibility, I guess, without trying to be mean to anyone's credentials there, were approved for. I think there was two different protected titles, but I don't know how much that actually did toward making it clear to a consumer who they should go to for certain types of advice.
Dan Bortolotti: It's hard to know what those titles mean to the public. We might make a distinction. Well, if you're going to call yourself a financial planner, then you need to have a certain designation.
If you're going to call yourself a portfolio manager, that is certainly a legal term. But amongst the general public, if you ask somebody, what's the difference between a portfolio manager and just an investment manager, I got to think most people are not going to appreciate the distinction. So that's not to say it isn't important to regulate it, but just to be aware that it may not have the result that you intend, may not have the effect that you are hoping it will.
Ben Felix: Yeah.
Tiah Tarumoto: I've got some evidence and numbers to back this up because of course, we all know that this community wants some numbers. If you look at FP Canada's 2026 financial stress index, 43% of Canadians said that money was their top stressor compared to 21% who cited personal health, which is kind of striking given that the health industry is so much more openly understood and navigated as we just discussed. I think it speaks a lot of volume.
Ben Felix: To make sure it's clear for the audience, this evidence is showing us that there's a whole bunch of stuff that you're going to go through, but this evidence is showing us that people need financial advice and are maybe not accessing it as efficiently as they should be.
Tiah Tarumoto: Precisely. As you said, when it comes to accessing advice, so 38% of Canadians work with a financial professional, but only 5% work specifically with a financial planner. That kind of goes back to the different roles and titles that we see in today's profession.
59% don't work with any financial planning professional at all. Just for scale, I believe there are 17,457 CFPs last counted.
Ben Felix: In Canada.
Tiah Tarumoto: In Canada. Then KPMG also did a study in 2025. They found that 80% of respondents with a professional financial plan felt secure about retiring at their desired age, while only 36% of those without a plan felt the same.
Another study also identified that the main barrier to seeking financial planning, 42% cited it was the cost and another 43% cited uncertainty about the process or its actual value that it brings to the table and the value proposition that it holds. Among people that had worked with a financial planner, KPMG reported that 56% said the value was completely worth the cost once they experienced it, and 37% said it was somewhat worth it. I think that's super interesting as well.
Dan Bortolotti: I think we'd all like to see that 56% number be a lot higher. It means a lot of people who are working with planners just aren't really getting value for money, which is a shame, or at least don't feel they are. I don't know what the difference between reality and perception is there, but certainly you want to see that number in the 90%, right?
Ben Felix: Financial advice, I've seen it referred to as a credence good, which is a good that it's hard to evaluate the value you've received even after you've received it. Healthcare is actually similar. You go to a doctor, you're not necessarily going to be better right away.
It's hard to know, did you get value for the money? Because they're both long-term things, compounding matters over long periods of time. It's hard to say that helped or it didn't until 20 years in the future.
Tiah Tarumoto: For me, the most interesting statistic was that only 44% reported a very clear understanding of what an actual financial plan entails, which I believe that's the biggest differentiator.
Ben Felix: I'm going to say something that might sound crazy, but I bet you that number is not that much higher even within the financial services community.
Dan Bortolotti: You mean that even advisors or planners would be hard-pressed in some ways?
Ben Felix: Broadly speaking, to people who work in financial services, I don't think that number would be that different.
Dan Bortolotti: Yeah, I don't think there's any question that the variability of the scope of services that people receive from financial professionals, it's so variable in this industry compared to almost any other. To go back to your health analogy, Tiah , if you went to your doctor, you probably wouldn't expect him or her to give you a comprehensive nutrition guideline. This is the way you should eat every day because you think, that's probably not really my family doctor's job.
Whereas in a financial planning relationship, I think sometimes clients will ask for things that we don't do or not appreciate that a lot of the things we do are never things they've thought to ask about. Obviously, we need to do a better job of explaining the scope of those services, but I feel like it is one profession where you could go to three or four or five different professionals who purport to offer the same services. In fact, the suite of services they offer can vary dramatically.
If you don't know what you're getting and you don't know what you're paying, no wonder so many people don't know if they're getting value from the relationship. It's just really hard to know.
Ben Felix: Not just the services, right, but I guess it's related. What are they licensed to give you in terms of advice or products? You can go to someone who's not licensed to make any product recommendations.
Financial products, like it or not, are a huge part of the financial planning process because people need to invest. They need insurance, they need mortgages. Those are all financial products, but you can go and talk to someone who's licensed to give broad advice, but not specific advice.
You can talk to someone who's only licensed to give specific advice on certain types of products. There's a lot of fragmentation across the financial planning process, which again, I think speaks to why it makes sense that people would not have a clear understanding of what this concept actually entails.
Tiah Tarumoto: That's a big component of why I think this conversation is super important because it's just the educational piece of it to inform people of how to diagnose what they need and who to go to because if I've got a toothache, I'm not going to the hospital. If my foot hurts, I'm not going to the dentist. It's the same thing for financial services.
I think we need to have that level of understanding eventually. I know it's not going to happen overnight, but eventually that's the goal. I have some more statistics that kind of look at the newer generations, but I won't go through those. Just a synopsis.
The findings really suggest that young adults, they are seeking more guidance, but professional advisors and planners are only one part of a much broader information ecosystem. They specifically highlighted that professional planning, self-directed planning, and having no plan at all are fundamentally different situations that require different responses. You've got AI, you've got technology, you've got digital tools, finfluencers such as someone that we know here.
Ben Felix: I don't count myself as a finfluencer.
Tiah Tarumoto: No?
Ben Felix: I don't know. Finfluencers are like trying to make people buy covered call ETFs.
Tiah Tarumoto: Some of them I'd classify as a finfluencer. Then you've got like Instagram and TikTok. I know there's a lot of reliable sources out there, but there's also a lot of trash.
There's a lot of trash and trying to navigate through how to deviate the two between what is useful and what is not, it's really difficult. I think consumers just need to be aware, but it's a point of educating them what to be aware of.
Ben Felix: You skipped over the statistics and then said the synopsis. I think statistics matter. For people age 18 to 34, 81% of them receive financial advice from at least one source, but only 20% are going to a professional. 57% are going to family or friends and 18% are going to social media.
Dan Bortolotti: It's got to be higher than 18%.
Ben Felix: Oh, for sure.
Dan Bortolotti: I'm not buying that number.
Tiah Tarumoto: That was from 2025. I'd be interested to see if they come out with a 2026 and how those numbers change. We'll see.
Only time will tell. Taking all of that into consideration, I have really just eight main discussion points that I specifically want to explore. The first one being financial planning is not a one-size-fits-all.
I think we've discussed this very thoroughly already, but one of the biggest misconceptions is that it's a one-size-fits-all service and it's not. We often picture one type of financial advisor or planner, one way of giving advice and that one ideal client, but that's not what it is. When we go back to comparing financial planning to healthcare, when you have a health concern, you might start off somewhere, but depending on your needs, you transfer somewhere else like a physiotherapist, a psychologist, or even a specialist, a naturopath.
As mentioned, financial planning should work the same. Not everyone needs the same type of diagnosis and the same type of care. People heal differently.
People recover differently. Someone looking for investment management help has very different needs for someone dealing with estate planning or even business succession. There's a lot of different goals that are out there that need to be understood.
We need to connect them with the right expertise. I don't think one approach needs to replace another. There's different approaches that work for different people.
Ultimately, I'd love to see a profession that's less focused on who gets to call themselves a financial planner and more focused on getting Canadians the right advice for the right person at the right time. Again, it very much goes to it depends. It sucks, but it depends.
Ben Felix: It's so complicated too, right? When people do specialize in something, it's pretty common for them to still service other types of clients. You might have someone that gets – I can't remember what the designation is called, but there's a designation specific to financial planning for people who are going through a divorce.
Someone gets that specialization, but they're probably going to take someone who's not going through a divorce as a client. I think you do have a lack of specialization that you don't have in healthcare because people are in business and their licenses aren't as restrictive like a physiotherapist can't practice dentistry, but a financial planner can do financial planning, broadly speaking, outside of whatever their specialization is. It does get a little bit fuzzy. It makes sense it would be difficult for consumers.
Tiah Tarumoto: Yeah, because you have that specific separation.
Dan Bortolotti: I know FP Canada, who is the governing body for the CFP designation is pretty adamant in that you have to, as a planner, be able to recognize when you are not able to give responsible advice and then refer to another professional accordingly. I think in my own practice, for example, I understand estate planning on a high level. I can give people generalized advice, but I'm not reading through your will and telling you which clauses need to be changed.
I'm going to refer you to an estate lawyer for that kind of thing. But again, I don't know what the legal requirement is. It wouldn't be very difficult and I'm sure advisors do it all the time, which is bluff and pretend that they know more than they know and maybe give advice they probably shouldn't, based on their level of specialized knowledge.
But again, yeah, that's a bit of a gray area. To your point, Ben, it's not hard and fast to define. You are not permitted to give any estate planning advice unless you have this designation.
It's not that tidy. And so it's hard as a client to know, well, I don't know, my advisor gave me all this information, but I'm not sure whether I should trust it or whether I should trust some of it, but not others. It's difficult, I think.
And that's why I think it's really important as a planner to be humble and admit to your client when you don't know. And you can say, I'm going to look into it and do my best, but at some point I might need to refer you to somebody who is a specialist.
Tiah Tarumoto: That's a really impactful thing too, because a lot of people aren't willing to kind of take the accountability and refer out to someone who possibly knows better. I think it's an ego thing, but it's also understanding that you're servicing in the best interest of your client. That is the whole intention.
You're trying to do what's best for the client. That is what you're there for. And that's a really good segue into the next discussion point that I want to talk about is what are Canadians actually paying for?
So we often get caught up in measuring the value of advice through portfolio performance or something that's tangible and easy to quantify, but financial planning, as we've mentioned, goes well beyond investments. We should be asking what meaningful improvements is a planner actually helping the client achieve? Are they making more informed decisions?
Are they avoiding unnecessary costs? Are they better prepared for retirement? Are they making progress towards their financial goals?
Are they achieving their financial goals? And I think it's our responsibility as planners and as a profession to demonstrate that value rather than simply tell clients that they're receiving it. I think that's really important.
The next discussion point is how do advice and compensation models shape the experience? They're all very important concepts, but compensation is important because it's how a financial planning professional gets paid and it influences how their business operates and just the overall incentive between the planner and the client. In Canada, there's several compensation models including commission, AUM, fee-based and salaried, so on.
I'm sure there's more that I'm missing. It's a little bit all over the place and it can be super confusing. I don't think these models are mutually exclusive or that one is necessarily better than the other.
I do have ones that I prefer, but I do think customers and consumers need to understand exactly what they're paying for, both the services they're receiving and the incentives that may exist behind it. So each model definitely has their own advantages and limitations depending on the consumer needs, but some people need that full service. Some people need that ongoing advisory relationship.
Others maybe just need that one-time consultation or just a second set of eyes over their shoulder.
Ben Felix: Even then, it's complicated, right? Maybe I'll just back up for a second for the benefit of listeners. Of the compensation models, you said commission-based where the advisor is paid by selling a product.
That's like you go to a butcher, you're going to get meat. You would hope that the consumer knows what to expect. You go to a car dealership, you're going to get a car.
You're not going to go there to buy your groceries. You go to an insurance salesperson, you're going to get insurance, especially if that's the only thing that they're licensed to sell. If they're licensed to sell multiple things, then I guess that's more like going to a grocery store.
You could probably buy your salad and your steak. The challenge with the commission-based model is that even if someone's duly licensed, they're going to sell products that pay commissions. In some cases, they may be incentivized to sell products that pay them a higher commission even if that product is not the best thing possible for their client.
Then we have the AUM model, which is how PWL operates. That's the firm's managing the assets of a client and charging a fee on those assets. Even within the AUM model, you can have very different service offerings.
I would consider PWL to be a full service wealth management firm, but in some AUM models, you're only getting investment management and you're not getting the ancillary services that we think are really important to doing the investment management well, but in some cases, you may only get investment management. That's another difference with – you can have multiple different service offerings even on the same compensation model. Fee-based, or they're often called fee-only or advice-only, is where you're going paying like an hourly or a project-based rate for financial planning work.
Then salary, many of the advisors at PWL are on salaries with a bit of a bonus component. We think that's really important to keep everybody aligned and working together as a team and not being incentivized to sell or bring on clients that we shouldn't otherwise be bringing on. I think a lot of people that work at banks are also on a salary plus bonus structure.
Anyway, we've got all these different compensation models, but within all of them, you can have very, very different service offerings and product offerings.
Tiah Tarumoto: There is a huge debate on if one is superior to the other, which I'd really like us to move beyond that and look at it from the perspective of, these are good people doing good things for good Canadians. The incentives behind it, as long as they're doing good things in the best interest of their client, I think that is the only thing that matters. Of course, there's nuances here and there, but that is the intention, that is the goal.
Dan Bortolotti: Yeah, I would argue though that the various models bring with them inherent incentives that could influence the advice, and I think that's really important. That doesn't mean that everyone who uses commission or anyone who's compensated by commission is fundamentally not going to act in the best interest of the client. That's not the point.
The point is they're incentivized to sell you products. The same biases though, like for example, in the AUM model, right? I mean, I'll give you a specific example that I've encountered numerous times.
If I get paid based on the assets that I manage and a client comes to me and says, I'm retiring, I have a choice between taking a lifetime pension or taking the commuted value of that pension. If I take the commuted value, I would send it to you and you would add it to my portfolio. Well, now I'm in a conflict of interest position or at least a potential conflict of interest.
If I advise the client to take the lifetime pension, that might be better for them, but it's definitely worse for me. If I advise them to take the commuted value, clearly I'm going to be compensated for that. So when I'm in a position like that, the first thing you do is just disclose it to the client. Just so you understand when I give you this advice, this is how it would affect me.
And I will say 99 times out of 100, I'm going to recommend they take the lifetime pension. But same thing if should I contribute to my TFSA or make a large prepayment on my mortgage. Same thing, I'm in a conflict of interest position.
So I need to disclose that and I need the client to understand that if I was so inclined, I could give you advice that would be better for me and not necessarily better for you. Again, an honest person is not going to actually do it, but we are in a position that cannot be avoided. It's about disclosure and helping the client appreciate that different compensation models bring with them different potential conflicts of interest.
Tiah Tarumoto: I think what it just boils down to is being a good person. It sounds so simple, but that is entirely what it is. That's what it boils down to.
Just being transparent, being open, and being a genuine human being trying to help other people. It's not that difficult. Another component of the discussion that I want to talk about is financial literacy and is it enough?
There's definitely an important difference between having that financial literacy and actually being able to apply that knowledge into your own life. I think that stems from a behavioral standpoint. Financial literacy is incredibly important and I think it should be pushed more within the education system.
But understanding financial concepts doesn't always mean you know how to navigate more complex decisions involving things such as competing goals and taxes and retirement investments and all that fun jazz. For example, you might know someone who invests and manages their own portfolio, but that doesn't necessarily mean that they know how to coordinate those investments with their broader financial goals or once they retire how to deaccumulate and what strategies to use. I think this is particularly interesting given the growth of DIY investing nowadays.
I love that investing has become more accessible and as you guys would say the problem has been solved with ETFs. But at what point does managing your own investments become insufficient to your broader financial situation?
Dan Bortolotti: There was a study done, I wish I had the information in front of me, but this idea that financial literacy is a double-edged sword because what it often does instead of increasing a client's ability to make a good decision, it just makes them overconfident. It's the classic Dunning-Kruger curve, right? This idea that well I consumed some financial literacy material, I did my own research quote-unquote and now I feel very confident in how the right way to invest.
But at the end of the day it's like do you really understand all of the subtleties? Like it's great, I'm not trying to denigrate people who try to learn, obviously. But the point is there is a tendency I think when people start to learn about any topic, not just investing, they end up being a bit overconfident until they cross over that threshold where they start to realize wow there's a lot of stuff I thought I knew or didn't even know I didn't know, the unknown unknowns. And I think that's probably an issue here as well.
Ben Felix: I don't know if I've seen that study, but there are definitely studies on not on necessarily the level of financial literacy, but the level of overconfidence in your own financial literacy that cause exactly that problem. That's an interesting question whether it has to be actual financial literacy or perceived financial literacy for it to cause this problem. Anyway, I agree Dan. I think it's a really important point.
Tiah Tarumoto: In my opinion, I think financial literacy and professional advice and professional planning, they shouldn't be competing with each other, which is interesting. I would love to see that study, Dan. They should complement each other.
I think that's the way it should be. But of course, I don't necessarily have as much experience with these communities as much as the both of you, so I would love to hear your opinions there as well, especially with the Rational Reminder community and the Reddit threads and everything.
Ben Felix: There is research on this. I don't think financial literacy is not a replacement for financial advice. It's complementary to it.
People who are more financially literate will tend to benefit more from professional financial advice, so there is a relationship there. But then on the online communities, I think they're really powerful. I know Bogleheads, for example, has benefited, I'm sure, many, many people.
The Reddit Personal Finance Community, same thing. The Rational Reminder community, I know, has lots of really good information in it, and all of them are good resources for people. But I think the challenge is, they can also be really hit and miss, and you can find, even within the Rational Reminder community, you can find these echo chambers of people who converge on ideas that I wouldn't always agree are good ideas.
I mean, there are some pretty wacky, nerdy threads in the Rational Reminder community where people are going off on discussing different alternative investments and stuff like that, and it's like, you can discuss those things in a way that's somewhat evidence- based, and people can get really excited about it in a sort of evidence-oriented community, but I wouldn't necessarily agree that that's good advice that most people should be taking. I think you can see the same thing on Reddit, where if someone posts on the Personal Finance Canada subreddit, I would say that on average, the advice is not bad, and then there are enough power users in that community that will usually say sensible things, and if someone's saying something that is not sensible, they'll get corrected or downloaded pretty quickly.
But I think the other challenge with platforms like Reddit is that people can create communities around any idea, and so if you decide or if you have an idea in your head that some really not smart investment strategy makes a lot of sense, you can find an online community that agrees with you, and you can go into that echo chamber and think you're really smart, and yes, I'm talking about covered calls.
Dan Bortolotti: Look, I hope it goes without saying that we're not suggesting that financial literacy is counterproductive, only that one always has to be aware that when you start on your journey of any kind of education and skill building, you have to do so with some humility, and you have to, like, I find like the more I learn, the more I know what I don't know. I'm way less confident about a lot of things today than I was 15 years ago, and it's not because I know less, it's the opposite. But I think, Tiah , to your point about literacy and professional advice not competing with each other, I mean, 100%. I always say if I could describe my ideal client, it would be one who knows the right questions to ask, understands the value that we provide, asks good questions about, hey, why are you doing this?
Because I don't understand why you're recommending I defer my CPP or take my RRSP withdrawals early. I want you to explain it to me. That's the best kind of client.
The client who just throws up their hands and say, I don't know, whatever, I trust you. Like, I appreciate that you trust me, but I also enjoy the back and forth with clients and answering those questions and being able to improve their knowledge. So, after working with a client for many years, hopefully they will understand a lot more about financial planning than they did before.
Even though they have delegated that responsibility to a professional, it has become a bigger part of their mindset as well. So, that's the ideal client.
Tiah Tarumoto: The next topic that I want to focus on is specifically, what does it mean to be a financial planning professional? Ben talked about this a little bit earlier, but we often and do use professional designations as a measure of credibility. But having a credential doesn't necessarily automatically make someone an expert in every area of financial planning.
And that is something that we need to understand. I say that as someone that's currently working towards my own credentials, and I have a growing list of letters that I'd eventually like to accumulate. So, I'm definitely not arguing against education.
I'm not doing that at all. But there's an important difference between education, practical experience, professional responsibility, so on. A designation can demonstrate that someone has completed a level of education examination, but how do we ensure that knowledge translates into good judgment, ethical decisions, and a positive client outcome?
I'm quite new to the profession. I don't have any designations myself, so I would love to hear your opinions and thoughts there.
Ben Felix: One of the things, and this is not meant to sound negative toward firms or the rest of the industry outside of PWL or to anybody who's currently in PWL and has joined, but it is such a consistent message that we hear. I mean, Tiah, you can maybe speak to this and tell me if I'm crazy. We often hear from people who have many years of experience in the industry and come to PWL that the caliber of planning and knowledge within our firm is so much different from elsewhere in the industry, and that folks who have even many years of experience learn so much so quickly after coming here.
I mean, that's always cool to hear, but I think it does speak to your point that you can have a professional designation and it doesn't necessarily mean that you're at the top of your game in the industry. Even when I joined PWL 13 years ago now, being around people like Justin Bender, who, Dan, of course, you work so closely with, he's like just a whole different plane of existence than most financial planners, but that's what you're exposed to or what I was exposed to when I joined this firm. To drive that point home, you can have lots of credentials, but that's not the same thing as being a professional.
I'd be curious real quick to hear before Dan says whatever he has to say, if he has anything to add, what your experience was like on that front.
Tiah Tarumoto: In my experience joining PWL, it's definitely a culture that you guys have cultivated, which is absolutely amazing. There's such a growth mindset within the culture, and it just motivates you to be better. It motivates you to learn more and understand things that you don't know and work towards them.
Ben Felix: You're also coming from the firm that you were with that joined PWL, as we mentioned earlier, it's like one of the top, I would say, financial planning firms in the country. That's maybe a bad example of what I was talking about. That's another cool thing about having firms like Macdonald Shymko join us is that we've leaned on the Macdonald, Shymko folks to build that.
We have a sort of, I don't know what I call it, a database of financial planning knowledge that our team relies on and our technology tools rely on. One of the first things we did is asked some of the Macdonald Shymko folks to work on that and contribute to that and make it better than it was, which we knew they would be able to, and they have. Anyway, Macdonald Shymko is probably a bad example of what I was talking about.
Tiah Tarumoto: I am very thankful and very lucky to have worked there for two and a half years. The growth was exponential. I wouldn't have wished to land somewhere else because I learned so much.
It was a lot. Don't get me wrong. My brain definitely expanded three times the size, but it was such an incredible experience.
Then seeing that translate over to PWL and the philosophy, the culture, the mentality, the growth mindset, it's super awesome. This is not a paid advertisement. Super awesome.
Ben Felix: You are being paid though by PWL, so maybe a little bit.
Tiah Tarumoto: I think that ultimately, consumers should understand what a professional is qualified to do, what responsibilities they owe their clients, and how it might be appropriate to bring in another specialist if needed. Like you said, there's a chartered divorce specialist, I believe that's what it is.
There's the TEP. I'm trying to think of what other designations are out there. There's a long array of designations and education pathways that people can take to specialize in these things, but there's a level of building the professional standards to help improve consistency, accountability, and public trust.
Dan Bortolotti: I think it's important to say here too, to build on what you were saying, Ben, which is that I had the privilege to work alongside Justin early in my career, over the last several years especially, as PWL has really improved its financial planning offering, making it more consistent, more quantifiable, etc. That culture of the people who you work with and the values that the firm hold to be important is going to have a much bigger influence than whatever education that you had. Everybody in this industry needs to have a certain level of education.
You need to get those designations for sure. I've talked about it in the past. The type of curriculum that a lot of the designations have, how relevant is that to what we do every day?
For example, I can remember getting licensed to be an investment advisor and so much of the education was about how to pick stocks, how to pick funds, fundamental analysis, technical analysis, how to calculate the value of barrels of oil, like the most absurd things that I would never use day to day. Everything I had to learn about index investing, I had to learn on my own or on the job. That's the investment strategy that I deliver to the clients.
Even on the financial planning side, I think credit to FP Canada for stressing the importance of planning and not selling, which is so much of what other designations seem to be designed to cater to. But even then, like again, and this is specific to different advisors' practices, at least a third of my clients have professional corporations. Try to go out and get a formal education on investing and financial planning in corporations.
It doesn't exist. Ben, you know this working with Mark, our Loonie Doctor, he self-taught so much of the amazing research that you guys have done. That's all primary research.
There's no secondary sources out there. People have asked me, even colleagues, what resources do you use to learn about corporate financial planning? I'm like, there's a few people that have done helpful papers, but you can't get a designation for that.
Ben Felix: No designation yet.
Dan Bortolotti: If your practice is not suited to that, like if you're someone, and certainly a lot of advisors don't work with a lot of corporations. Some of them specifically screen them out.
I've definitely spoken to fee-only planners who say, I don't do corporate planning, period. I don't blame them because it's a whole different kettle of fish that they might not be able to do. It really comes back, I think, to what we said before, which is just having the humility to recognize when you're not a specialist in something and just say to the client, I will do what I can, but this is not an area that I'm going to pretend to be good at.
I'm going to refer you to someone else. In the case of corporate planning, maybe it's an accountant or somebody, but even accountants may not understand.
Ben Felix: I was going to say, yeah.
Dan Bortolotti: Accountants are great at what they do, but they're not necessarily good at incorporating investment planning into their projections. You really do have to be, as a client or as someone who's hiring a planner, and this is challenging, I appreciate it, but you have to understand the scope of the services you're going to get and the limits because no one is everything to everyone. You have to find a good fit with a professional who delivers services that are relevant to you and who will be able to refer you to somebody else if they can't do it directly.
Ben Felix: I will say, even though it's not a formal, it doesn't give you a designation. Mark Soth and I did design the Money Scope Podcast as a curriculum for people who want to learn about corporate financial planning.
Dan Bortolotti: Excellent.
Tiah Tarumoto: This conversation is a perfect segue into the next topic that I want to discuss, is developing the next generation of planners. I don't have my CFP right now. I'm currently working towards it.
I don't have any designations or credentials, so I'm currently going through this mass education road trip right now while I'm working full-time. I will say that trying to apply the technical knowledge while working has been so much more meaningful to my professional development because I'm actually able to apply these examples and understand it comprehensively, whereas if I wasn't working full-time and I wasn't indulged in these examples and looking at these case studies, I don't think it would have processed as much. I think that's a big thing that students and early career professionals are facing right now.
There's a huge disconnect, and I think many people don't realize the different career paths within the financial planning profession, and that's a huge missed opportunity because there's a big difference between learning financial planning concepts and actually applying them to someone's real life. Real clients don't always fit the textbook examples that we're given, and financial planning involves so much more than technical knowledge. We look at communication, critical thinking, the ethics behind it, behavioral finance, and relationship management.
I could probably go on, and we need to recognize that entering the profession takes a significant amount of investment of time and money. Some people are supported through their works and others are not. Credentials, continuing education, and gaining the actual practical experience can create barriers for emerging professionals.
Established planners and firms can help by providing mentorships. Those are super meaningful. I personally have a few mentors that have been nothing less than amazing for my development, even just meaningful entry-level opportunities for early professionals and exposure to just different career pathways.
That level of education is specifically for people within the profession, and if we want a stronger profession in the future, we need to invest in those people and build it up.
Dan Bortolotti: It's a good observation. The people that we want at the forefront of the profession going forward, the younger people who are entering this profession now, need to be excellent human beings, not just technically strong, because more and more, let's agree, AI is going to take over a lot of the technical aspects of what we do, but it cannot take over the human aspects. Ben, it was Brian Portnoy that you were mentioning before that you had worked with him on that How I Invest book.
He talks about this, and if I remember the metaphor right, he talks about the mechanic and the guide, and this idea that you need a mechanic in the sense that you need someone with the technical expertise to fix things, but you also need a guide once the car is fixed to show you what direction to drive it. I think the same is true of a financial planner. They need to be both.
They need to have the technical expertise. We are increasingly able to rely on technology to help us with that, but we can never be replaced on the other side of it, which is to be the human guide for people in their financial life. Technical expertise is a commodity, but the human touch, the relationship that you develop with a client is not and can't be.
Ben Felix: That's such a good point, Dan. I think conversations like this are really important for, to your point Tiah, the next generation of financial planners and people coming into our industry because, as you've talked about, people don't know what's out there. I wish I had data on this.
I only have a whole bunch of anecdotes, but many people who are not currently in our industry have listened to this podcast and then made a career change into financial planning because they realized, one, this is really interesting because of all the elements that you just talked about, Dan. You're weaving in all of the combination of technical expertise, textbook information, and human empathy and the ability to interact with humans and build trust with humans to help make good decisions. All of those things together, that's really cool.
I think what we do is genuinely one of the most interesting professions that exists. People realize that and then they realize there's a way to do it that does not require selling products, which I think our industry has a reputation for. A lot of people are like, wow, what a cool career, and they've gone and made that switch themselves.
That happened because they've listened to us talk about this and realized, oh, all of this interesting stuff goes into this. Oh, wow, financial decisions are actually really important. Wouldn't it be great to help people make those?
Oh, wow, there's a good way to do it. There are business models that are not predatory and don't require selling products that people don't need.
Tiah Tarumoto: This topic specifically is something that I'm super passionate about because I do a lot of volunteer work for the Financial Planning Association of Canada. There is a student membership and I am the student liaison on the board of directors. I've been in that position for about two years now.
My whole role is to get students out there on the forefront because they often get filtered through larger institutions, whether it's banking, insurance, investments, or just traditional advisory roles. They don't understand that there's this whole community of people that are doing good planning for Canadians. It's such an epiphany for people to understand.
I might be 5'1", but there's something fierce in me and I'm super committed to pushing this profession forward. I'm all hands on deck. I remember it very vividly.
It was one of my first presentations I did for a group of students when I first joined FPAC as a student liaison. This was in person. I'm local to Vancouver. I did this whole spiel. I had a PowerPoint presentation. It went over amazing.
One of the students in the back kind of raises his hand. It was the first question. He looks at me and goes, you don't sell financial product? I looked at him and I go, no, no, I don't. I don't sell product. He goes, yes.
It was such a revolutionary moment for me. I'm like, yeah, this is what I'm going to have to work on. This is what I'm going to do. That just lit a spark underneath me and hasn't stopped since then. That was pretty cool.
Ben Felix: Very cool.
Tiah Tarumoto: The next topic of discussion is why should different financial professionals collaborate? I think we've touched point on this multiple times throughout this so far. One of the best ways to understand the diversity of financial planning is to go back to the healthcare analogy.
When someone's in an accident, they might receive initial care at a hospital to address immediate needs, broken bones, concussions, or whatever. But once they're at a point of stability, they transition to other professionals, depending on the circumstances and depending on their bodies. That could look like a physiotherapist for physical recovery, a counselor for emotional support, or just some type of specialization that provides medication or rehabilitation for that person, for that individual.
I think, like I said, financial planning should reflect the same. Each professional service provides something different and not every single service is intended to be a lifelong solution. Some address immediate needs while others provide ongoing specialized care. I think it should be the same.
Dan Bortolotti: I'll say too that from a client's perspective, when professionals collaborate or when you have a team acting together, it's the best client experience. I've seen it so many times. It might be the advisory team.
It's all internal. You have a lead advisor and then that advisor has associates who also work with the client. That's one thing.
But I even mean externally. For example, I know with a number of our clients, we work quite closely with the accountants and we have a good relationship with them. We'll get on the phone.
Sometimes we'll do meetings with the three of us, the client, myself, and the accountant. We're not professionally associated. We don't have any compensation agreement or anything like that.
But from the client's perspective, they feel like, now I've got a team in my corner, not just one person. I think anytime you can collaborate with specialists and let each person handle their own thing. I guess you as the lead advisor have to be the quarterback, but you can definitely work with others.
I think clients appreciate that more than somebody maybe who feigns expertise in all of these areas and tries to do everything themselves. People like to feel like they've got more than one person in their corner.
Ben Felix: Do a lot of collaboration with accountants, like you said, Dan, and clients do appreciate that. It's interesting with accountants because they come with deep expertise in tax. It doesn't always translate to financial planning.
A long-term financial planning decision from a tax perspective can be very different from what's going to save you the most tax in a single year. We've had a lot of really interesting dialogue with accountants who, because of the reputation financial services has, have approached us with skepticism. But then when they see, oh, that's what you're bringing to the table, that long-term perspective, and we were able to show analysis, well, no, they should do this.
We think they should do this, not that. Here's the data to back that up. Then the accountant's able to see, oh, okay, that makes sense.
I see why you're giving that advice. Those can be really powerful collaborations. Estate planning lawyers is another frequent collaboration.
Insurance is another frequent collaboration that we've recently brought in-house for one of the reasons that we've been talking about. The conflicts of interest in insurance can make it difficult. We've built an insurance function inside of PWL where the person giving the advice is not incentivized to sell the product.
They're incentivized to give good advice, but they're not going to earn a commission for selling an insurance product. That's another area of collaboration or different area of expertise that is a tricky one to navigate, but that's how we've recently decided to approach it.
Tiah Tarumoto: Dan, going back to your analogy, it's really hard to play a football game with a quarterback, just a quarterback.
Tiah Tarumoto: Yeah. My last point of discussion is what should the profession look like in 20 years? This is just for me personally because I am a young individual and I do plan to stay in the profession unless I, for some reason, become a florist.
In 20 years down the road, I have a vision of what I want the profession to look like and how are we going to achieve that? I think ultimately it comes down to improving both the quality and accessibility of advice and planning for Canadians. There's so many opportunities to evolve through technology, transparent service offerings, different services and levels of financial planning, better referral systems, financial literacy, and just stronger professional development.
There's an array of opportunities that we can jump on and we can do so much better helping consumers understand and comprehend and identify what they need. What that looks like, I don't know yet, but I've got high hopes.
Dan Bortolotti: Don't underestimate the importance of that. Just honestly having the passion and the curiosity is a huge benefit for anybody in this profession, I think, because it's going to change. It's going to evolve over the next few years.
People more of my vintage have to be aware that, look, the industry is going to change over the next 10 years and it's going to be in the hands of younger people and the industry needs people with that kind of enthusiasm and curiosity and willingness to evolve in order to figure out the best way to serve clients. Because the industry has failed in many ways in the past. It's 100% getting better.
I've seen it getting better just in the last decade or so, let alone 30 years or so. And I think it's just going to keep getting better, but it will not be without challenges. And as a firm too, we need to stock the company with young people who are going to carry that torch.
Ben Felix: He's talking about you, Tiah.
Tiah Tarumoto: I'm excited. I'm ready to rumble.
Dan Bortolotti: Excellent.
Ben Felix: We still have a long way to go too. I was looking for an unrelated reason earlier at what is the largest fund in Canada? Do you guys know what it is?
Dan Bortolotti: It's got to be like a RBC dividend fund or something like that.
Ben Felix: Balanced, RBC balanced fund.
Dan Bortolotti: Okay.
Ben Felix: An actively managed fund with a total expense ratio just under 2%, commission-based fund, which means it's likely largely being sold through the bank. And it's like, that's fine.
And people may be getting good advice through their bank financial advisor and whatever. But in the United States, the largest fund is the Vanguard US total market ETF.
Dan Bortolotti: VTI.
Ben Felix: Yeah. I think it's VTI. Yeah. Very different.
Dan Bortolotti: It's like a trillion dollars or something like that.
Ben Felix: I think it's two. I think it's more than that.
Dan Bortolotti: Unbelievable.
Ben Felix: We're still way behind, at least on the investment front, but that cascades into where are people getting financial planning advice?
It's largely still from, at least if we use assets under management as a proxy, it's largely still from advisors who are selling a financial product for a commission or a bonus, at least.
Dan Bortolotti: That hits on one of the age old challenges and frustrations that I've always had as I've advocated for DIY investing versus working with an advisor. We've talked a lot about who should work with an advisor and who can do DIY. I've spoken with a lot of people who have no interest in being DIY. They just know it's not for them. They want advice. They're willing to pay for it.
But the problem is, if your portfolio is relatively small, it's very difficult to find good quality advice at a reasonable fee. Ben, you talk about that balanced fund, for example. Okay, let's say it's 2%.
Well, that's an extremely high fee. However, if the client has $50,000 to invest, they're paying $1,000 a year for that fund, and if that allows them to work with an advisor who actually does cash flow analysis, saving strategies, good quality advice that's worth $1,000, maybe that's not the worst model. What's the alternative?
Our fees here are a lot lower than that on a percentage term, but we can't offer the services to all comers. We have to impose some kind of minimum or some kind of threshold. It varies with different advisors and different teams.
But I think it's fair to say that the most underserved clients, I think, are those with maybe less than $100,000 or so to invest, because those are people who are going to find it most difficult to get planning-focused advice at a reasonable cost. I wish I had a great solution to that, but I just don't. There are some potential solutions, but none of them is perfect. That's just an ongoing challenge that I would love the industry to be able to solve.
Ben Felix: I think advice only is helping, but as Dave Chilton talked about when he was on this podcast recently, there's still a bit of an implementation gap, especially for, probably for the people who need it the most, who need the most help with implementation, because they're busy, but they have little other assets and financial resources to buy themselves time. They could probably benefit more than most people from financial advice, but they're also least able to pay for it and get ongoing support. It's the Vanguard Morningstar Total Stock Market Index Fund. It used to be called the Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund, and it tracks the Morningstar US Total Market Index, which to be called the CRSP US Total Market Index. It has a bunch of different classes, but across all classes, it's got 2.3 trillion in AUM.
Dan Bortolotti: At Vanguard, that would include the ETF, because the ETF is one class of the mutual fund.
Ben Felix: In the data I'm looking at, VTI shows up as a separate entity. I don't know.
Dan Bortolotti: Wow.
Ben Felix: Anyway, it's multiple trillions. Yeah.
Dan Bortolotti: That's a pretty staggering number. Yeah. You wonder why they can charge three basis points as the fee, because that's a pretty big fee on 2.4 trillion.
Ben Felix: Yeah. It's crazy. Tiah , do you want to go to your conclusion?
Tiah Tarumoto: Just going back to the question, does every Canadian need a financial planner? I've said it once and I'll say it again, but the answer is it truly depends on what we mean by need. So what kind of diagnosis is someone facing?
What support can they reasonably access for a reasonable cost? And the more useful objective is just to ensure that Canadians can recognize their options and obtain the appropriate help when they need it and how they need it. A healthy profession does not require every planner to serve the same clients, offer identical services, or follow the same business model.
It does require professionals to understand their responsibilities, communicate transparently, recognize the limitations of their expertise, and put suitable client outcomes at the center of the work. So client first, that's the way it should be. Again, for emerging professionals, students, the opportunity is to help build that future, one where diversity of the profession is a strength.
We can collaborate, we are encouraged, and the consumers can make informed decisions about financial advice and planning. The question here becomes, if we designed the Canadian financial planning profession around the diverse needs of Canadians today, rather than around the business models and assumptions inherited from the past, what would we change first? That's kind of my long-winded answer of saying, it depends.
Dan Bortolotti: Thanks, Tiah.
Ben Felix: Your notes say that you're going to insert a mic drop. How are you going to? Okay, okay. That was great. Yeah, it's cool to hear your thoughts and insights and observations as someone coming up in the industry.
Not like a regular person, I would call you a high achiever, and you're involved in lots of extracurricular volunteer stuff. You're doing your designations, you're grinding hard as a professional, but also as a student of the industry. Very interesting to hear how your mind is processing all of this stuff and reflecting on it.
Tiah Tarumoto: It's been a super cool experience. Like I said, I'm very observational in that sense, so I've been able to put myself at conferences, networking events within communities, and just observe. Because the demographic of financial professionals, there is a specific age that they typically lay under, so being able to have a young perspective and go from there is super, super cool. I'm super excited because I think there's something exciting.
Ben Felix: Awesome. We do have one review from Apple Podcasts to read. Under SEC regulations, we are required to disclose whether a review, which may be interpreted as a testimonial, was left by a client, whether any direct or indirect compensation was paid for the review, which it was not, or whether there are any conflicts of interest related to the review, which there are not.
As reviews are generally anonymous, including this one, we are unable to identify if the reviewer is a client or disclose any such conflicts of interest. Tiah, you can go ahead and read this review.
Tiah Tarumoto: Awesome. Hey there, Ben, Cameron, and Dan. I've been a listener of your RR Podcast since the early days of the pandemic from Toronto.
As such, RR has been my reliable Thursday morning audio partners for a walk or gym exercise since early 2020, or approaching seven years. I have learned a lot, and it's been comforting and confidence-inspiring to add your fact-based accompaniment to my financial planning life from my late-stage career life into early retirement. Please keep up the wonderful work, and I hope it's paying dividends for PWL in the form of client and business growth.
As a cross-border individual myself, Canada-US, I remember reaching out to one of you in the early days and asking whether your service offerings include cross-border clients. I recall that the answer was no, but I wonder if that has changed in light of your merger in early 2025. In any case, I would personally put in a vote for practical cross-border financial planning topics for the RR Podcast, especially if that is now in the PWL wheelhouse. All the best, Mark C., not a client of PWL Toronto, Canobie, from Canada.
Ben Felix: That's their user name. People always put funny user names in the reviews. I don't know if I've ever seen that word either. I would not have known how to pronounce that word either - accompaniment. It's a good thing you're here, Dan. We've got an adult in the room. Thanks everyone for listening. Thanks, Tiah for coming on and sharing your thoughts. That was great.
Tiah Tarumoto: Thank you for having me.
Dan Bortolotti: Thanks, Tiah.
Disclaimer:
Portfolio management and brokerage services in Canada are offered exclusively by PWL Capital, Inc. (“PWL Capital”) which is regulated by the Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization (CIRO) and is a member of the Canadian Investor Protection Fund (CIPF). Investment advisory services in the United States of America are offered exclusively by OneDigital Investment Advisors LLC (“OneDigital”). OneDigital and PWL Capital are affiliated entities, and they mostly get on really well with each other. However, each company has financial responsibility for only its own products and services.
Nothing herein constitutes an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security. Occasionally we tell you not to buy crappy investments in the first place, but that’s not the same thing as telling you to sell them.
This communication is distributed for informational purposes only; the information contained herein has been derived from sources believed to be “truthy,” but not necessarily accurate. We really do try, but we can’t make any guarantees. Even if nothing we say is fundamentally wrong, it might not be the whole story.
Furthermore, nothing herein should be construed as investment, tax or legal advice. Even though we call the podcast “your weekly reality check on sensible investing and financial decision making,” you should not rely on us when making actual decisions, only hypothetical ones.
Different types of investments and investment strategies have varying degrees of risk and are not suitable for all investors. You should consult with a professional adviser to see how the information contained herein may apply to your individual circumstances. It might not apply at all. Honestly, you can probably ignore most of it.
All market indices discussed are unmanaged, do not incur management fees, and cannot be invested in directly. Which is a shame, because it would be awesome if you could.
All investing involves risk of loss: including loss of money, loss of sleep, loss of hair, and loss of reputation. Nothing herein should be construed as a guarantee of any specific outcome or profit.
Past performance is not indicative of or a guarantee of future results. If it were, it would be much easier to be a Leafs fan.
All statements and opinions presented herein are those of the individual hosts and/or guests, are current only as of this communication’s original publication date. No one should be surprised if they have all since recanted. Neither OneDigital nor PWL Capital has any obligation to provide revised statements and/or opinions in the event of changed circumstances.
Is there an error in the transcript? Let us know! Email us at info@rationalreminder.ca.
Be sure to add the episode number for reference.
Participate in our Community Discussion about this Episode:
https://community.rationalreminder.ca/t/does-every-canadian-need-a-financial-planner-436/43751
Sources From Today’s Episode:
https://zbib.org/9c0bf9b6a0ab4015a02df9a00df91153
Links From Today’s Episode:
Stay Safe From Scams — https://pwlcapital.com/stay-safe-online/
Rational Reminder on Apple Podcasts — https://itunes.apple.com/ca/podcast/the-rational-reminder-podcast/id1426530582.
Rational Reminder on Spotify —https://open.spotify.com/show/6RHWTH9iW7hdnA7eAg7ukO?si=fe7f60349b584026
Rational Reminder on Instagram — https://www.instagram.com/rationalreminder/
Rational Reminder on YouTube — https://www.youtube.com/channel/
Benjamin Felix — https://pwlcapital.com/our-team/
Benjamin on X — https://x.com/benjaminfelix
Benjamin on LinkedIn — https://www.linkedin.com/in/benjaminwfelix/
